1

A Hectic Book Review – Instant: The Story of Polaroid by Christopher Bonanos

This was my third time checking Instant: The Story of Polaroid out of our public library. In each prior case, I had left with an armful of books, and this one got returned, the pages unread. I finally decided that I would only bring two books home on this trip, so I actually managed to open the book this time.

And I couldn’t put it down.

Christopher Bonanos does a great job of laying out the history of Edwin Land, the founder of Polaroid. In fact, this is really a biography of Land. But that’s understandable, since he was so intricately tied into Polaroid’s inception, rise, and (unfortunately) it’s fall. With the exception of the last chapter or two, this is really the Edwin Land story.

I had read that Steve Jobs had made several pilgrimages to visit Land, and Jobs viewed Land as one of his mentors. As I got deeper into Instant, I could see why. Their lives were very similar. Their personalities were very similar. And their demands for excellence mirrored each other completely. They were both very driven…and very successful.

Having spent a large portion of 2013 and a bit of 2014 reading about Steve Jobs, Apple, and Pixar it was fascinating to pick up a book that portrayed another company with a somewhat similar path. The primary difference between Polaroid and Apple seems to be that Apple was able to rise from the ashes, not once, but a couple of times. And today Apple appears to be going strong. By contrast, Polaroid is barely hanging on to life.

I grew up in the age of Polaroid.

That meant that I was among the first generation that was able to record and view our history while it was being made. I remember the distinctly vinegar smell of the chemicals that had to be sponged onto a B&W Polaroid photo. I remember taking several versions of the same family photo because somebody wasn’t properly in place. I remember passing around the photos immediately after taking them. Polaroids weren’t just a way of capturing a moment, they were a way of sharing that moment in the present.

I never really thought about being on the cutting edge of photography back in the 1960’s. I remember my Dad teaching me how to take photos with his Polaroid and then how to care for the pictures as they developed. I remember being clearing instructed to never touch the surface lest you would leave fingerprints and ruin the image. I remember carefully passing the snapshots from person to person at family gatherings, carefully touching only the edges…making the actual passing something of a party game.

Instant: The Story of PolaroidThroughout the book, memories of those early days of my introduction to photography were given new life. While I was much more aware of the later models of the Polaroid cameras, I do have some memories of the cameras from their heyday. I clearly remember B&W photos from Dad’s Polaroid and I remember the fascination when we developed our first Color photos. Imagine that, you could actually take photos of the world in full color.

Looking back through an album of those old photos, the colors have faded somewhat. They were never really completely true-to-life, but today they add a very nostalgic tinge to every Polaroid. Trust me, the 1960’s and 1970’s weren’t really murky and a bit blurry…at least not the life that I led.

Another interesting aspect of Instant is the cautionary tale that it tells. Polaroid owned the instant photography market. Even Kodak and Fuji into the field didn’t topple the little company that could. Sure, there was a long, drawn-out court battle between Polaroid and Kodak (won by Polaroid), but the real dragon that destroyed Polaroid as a company was the eventual advancement of technology. The development of digital photography is what really killed the company. By the time digital photography was beginning to take off, Edwin Land had left Polaroid, and the folks in charge of the company just didn’t see digital photography as a reasonable market to compete. After reading the book, I wonder what Edwin Land would’ve done? I really think he would have embraced the new method and driven Polaroid to develop digital products.

Throughout the book, Land’s tenacity and genius are often highlighted. His attention to detail was astounding. I never realized that the bubbled areas on the top and bottom of the Polaroid photos were were the actual chemicals were housed that developed the photos. Frankly, I’d never thought about it. I imagined that the film cartridge actually held all the chemicals and that’s where the magic happened. Having spent countless hours in photo darkrooms developing and printing my own images, my level or respect for all things Polaroid rose immensely when I discovered that a tiny photo lab was embedded in each print. What an amazing feat of technology coupled with astounding engineering.

The book reminds me of other engineering companies that struggled with successfully marketing their products. Or more aptly, struggled with keeping up with the market. I worked for Texas Instruments for many years, and during that time I was intimately aware of the engineering culture there. Compaq computer was another company that lived (and died) by their engineering. National Semiconductor was another. And even the great Hewlett-Packard has struggled to convert their engineering prowess into market viability. All those companies have had success, and some have been the leader in their market…but technology has a way of moving on. Getting smaller, faster, and more capable. Instant: The Story of Polaroid is a dire warning to any tech company…keep moving as the marketplace moves or get left behind.

The book is a very easy read, and if you have any interest in the early days of instant photography, I would highly recommend it. If  your curious about how a sole engineer, with a brilliant mind, can make a difference to an entire society…again, I’d highly recommend it. The story of Polaroid is intimately interwoven with the story of Edwin Land. Both are fascinating!

Weekend Book Club

1 thought on “A Hectic Book Review – Instant: The Story of Polaroid by Christopher Bonanos”

  1. Sounds like an interesting book for any photography fans out there. I would never had thought if looking for this book but I do love a good photography book.
    Thanks for joining the #weekendbookclub

Comments are closed.